Stock options explained for engineers: strike price, vesting and dilution
· 5 min read
An offer letter says “20,000 options”. Is that a lot? There is no way to tell. Equity is the part of compensation engineers understand least, and the share count on its own carries almost no information.
What an option is
A stock option is the right to buy a share later at a price fixed today, called the strike price. If the share price rises above the strike, the difference is your gain. If it does not, the option is worth nothing — it is “underwater”. Restricted stock units (RSUs) are different: they are shares given to you outright as they vest, so they keep some value even if the price falls.
Vesting and the cliff
You do not receive the grant at once. The common schedule is four years with a one-year cliff. Leave before twelve months and you get nothing. At the cliff, a quarter vests in one go, and the rest follows monthly or quarterly. For a grant of 4,800 options, that is 1,200 at the cliff and 100 a month afterwards.
Why the share count means nothing
Compare two offers. Company A gives 20,000 options: a $2 strike, a $2.50 share price and 100 million shares outstanding. Company B gives 8,000 options: a $1 strike, a $6 share price and 10 million shares outstanding.
- A: 0.02% of the company, with a paper value of ($2.50 − $2) × 20,000 = $10,000.
- B: 0.08% of the company, with a paper value of ($6 − $1) × 8,000 = $40,000.
The smaller grant is four times the ownership and four times the paper value.
Dilution
Each time a company raises money it issues new shares, and every existing holder's percentage shrinks. If you own 1% and the company sells 20% of itself in a new round, you own 0.8%. That is not necessarily bad: a smaller share of a much more valuable company can be worth more. But expect several rounds before any exit, and expect your percentage to fall with each.
Four questions to ask
- How many shares are outstanding, fully diluted? This turns a share count into a percentage.
- What is the strike price, and what was the price per share in the last funding round?
- What is the vesting schedule, and what happens to vested options if I leave? Many plans give only 90 days to exercise.
- Are there preferences that put investors ahead of common shareholders in a sale?
A company that will not answer the first two is telling you something.
How to think about it
Paper value is not money. Startup equity is illiquid and high-variance: most grants end up worth little, and a few are worth a great deal. A reasonable approach is to choose the offer on salary, the work and the people, and treat equity as a lottery ticket with better-than-usual odds. Tax treatment of options varies by country and by type of grant, so get advice specific to your situation before exercising.
If you manage people, you will be on the other side of this conversation. Explain the numbers plainly, give candidates what they need to work out their ownership, and never promise an outcome.
