Managing People

Lesson 4 · People

Hiring

The highest-leverage, hardest-to-reverse decision you make. Treat it like engineering.

Hiring is the highest-leverage and hardest-to-reverse decision a manager makes. Start with a scorecard: the outcomes this role must deliver in its first year, and the competencies those outcomes require. Without one, every interviewer assesses a different job.

Structured interviews — the same questions for every candidate, scored against a rubric, with each interviewer covering an assigned area — predict performance better than unstructured conversation and reduce bias. Interviewers should write their feedback independently before the debrief, so the first or loudest voice does not anchor everyone else.

Hiring is also a funnel. If 25% of onsite candidates get an offer and 80% accept, each hire takes five onsites. Multiply back through the earlier pass rates and you know how many candidates, and how many interviewer hours, a headcount plan really requires.

Picture it

A team needs two hires this quarter. In their funnel, 20% of phone screens reach onsite, 25% of onsites get an offer and 80% of offers are accepted. One hire takes 1 ÷ (0.20 × 0.25 × 0.80) = 25 phone screens. Two hires means 50 screens and 10 onsites; at five interviewer-hours per onsite that is 50 hours of engineering time before debriefs. The manager puts that time in the sprint plan instead of pretending it is free.

Key formulas & frameworks

Scorecard
Outcomes for year one + Competencies they require
Candidates needed
Hires ÷ (Pass rate₁ × Pass rate₂ × … × Accept rate)
Structured interview
Same questions + Scoring rubric + Independent written feedback

Practice

Score: 0 / 5

Question 1

Q1.20% of onsite candidates receive an offer and 50% of offers are accepted. How many onsites does one hire take?

Question 2

Q2.Why should interviewers write feedback before the debrief?

Question 3

Q3.Unstructured, conversational interviews predict job performance better than structured ones.

Question 4

Q4.You need three hires. 25% of phone screens reach onsite, 40% of onsites get an offer, and 75% of offers are accepted. How many phone screens do you need?

Question 5

Q5.What should come first when opening a role?

Up nextTeam size & communication

Next lesson