People

How to give feedback engineers can use: the SBI model

The situation-behavior-impact (SBI) feedback model with examples for engineering managers: praise, corrective feedback, and the mistakes that make feedback fail.

· 5 min read

Most feedback fails before it starts, because it is about the person rather than what they did. “You need to be more of a team player” is impossible to act on and easy to resent. The situation–behavior–impact model, developed at the Center for Creative Leadership, fixes that with a simple structure.

The structure

  • Situation: when and where. “In Tuesday's design review…”
  • Behavior: what the person did — observable, not interpreted. “…you interrupted Lena twice before she finished her point…”
  • Impact: the effect it had. “…she stopped contributing, and we lost her view on the caching approach.”

Then stop and ask: “How did you see it?” You rarely have the whole story, and the conversation that follows is where the change happens.

It works for praise too

“In the incident last night (situation), you posted an update every twenty minutes even while you were debugging (behavior). Support said it was the calmest outage they have handled, and two customers thanked us (impact).” Specific praise tells people what to repeat. “Great job” tells them nothing.

Behavior, not character

  • Character: “You're careless.” Behavior: “The last two PRs merged without tests.”
  • Character: “You're not a team player.” Behavior: “You declined the last three review requests.”
  • Character: “You're negative.” Behavior: “In planning you raised four objections and no alternatives.”

Behavior can change. Character feels like a verdict, and people defend themselves against verdicts.

Timing and ratio

Give feedback within days, not at the review. Give it privately when it is corrective; give praise publicly if the person is comfortable with that. And give much more positive feedback than corrective: people who hear praise regularly hear correction as useful, not as an attack.

Common mistakes

  • The feedback sandwich: praise–criticism–praise buries the message and makes praise feel like a warning.
  • Hiding behind others: “people have been saying…” makes it impossible to discuss specifics.
  • Saving it up: a list of six-month-old examples feels like an ambush.
  • No follow-up: notice and say so when the behavior changes.

Quick check

3 questions from the related lessons. Answers are explained, and the ones you get right count towards your progress.

Question 1

Q1.Which statement follows the SBI model?

Question 2

Q2.An engineer keeps missing deadlines. It turns out nobody told them which of their four projects mattered most. What is the root cause?

Question 3

Q3.Which of these is task conflict?

Practice this in a lesson

Each engMBA lesson pairs a short explanation with practice questions that grade themselves. Free, with no signup.

See the full curriculum

Keep reading