Blog

How to run a one-on-one: a guide for new engineering managers

· 5 min read

The one-on-one is the most useful meeting a manager has and the one most often done badly. Done well, it is where you hear about problems while they are small, give feedback while it is fresh, and find out what each person wants from their career. Done badly, it is a status update that could have been a message.

The basics

  • Cadence: weekly or every two weeks, for 30 to 60 minutes.
  • Ownership: it is the report's meeting. Their topics come first.
  • Reliability: move it if you must, but do not cancel. Repeated cancellations tell the person where they rank.
  • Privacy: one-to-one, and what is said stays there unless you agree otherwise.

A simple agenda

  • Their topics (about half the time): whatever is on their mind.
  • Your topics: feedback, context from above, anything you need from them.
  • Looking ahead: growth, upcoming work, obstacles you can remove.

Keep a shared document with running notes and action items. It makes follow-through visible and gives quieter people a place to add topics beforehand.

Questions that open things up

  • What is taking more of your time than it should?
  • What is one thing I could do differently that would help you?
  • Which part of your work are you enjoying most at the moment? Least?
  • Is there a decision you are waiting on?
  • What would you like to be doing a year from now that you are not doing today?

Then wait. New managers fill silences; experienced ones let them work. The useful answer usually comes after the pause.

Giving feedback in a one-on-one

Use the situation–behavior–impact structure. “In Tuesday's design review, you cut Lena off twice before she finished. She stopped contributing, and we lost her input on the caching approach.” Then ask for their view. It is specific and it is about what the person did, so it is hard to argue with. Do not save it up: feedback that waits for a performance review arrives as a surprise.

Common mistakes

  • Turning it into a status report. Status belongs in standups and trackers.
  • Doing most of the talking. Aim to listen for more than half the meeting.
  • Skipping it when things are busy — the moment it matters most.
  • Never discussing growth. If career conversations only happen at review time, people conclude you do not think about theirs.
  • Solving every problem yourself. Ask what they have tried and what they would do next.

A good test: if the meeting were cancelled for a month, would either of you miss anything? If the answer is no, change what you talk about.

Practice this in a lesson

Each engMBA lesson pairs a short explanation with practice questions that grade themselves. Free, with no signup.

See the full curriculum

Keep reading